Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

 

:icondenlm:
You had me worried for a while there: You were telling again instead of showing. The first 20 or so paragraphs could easily be slashed to 10. You belabor the point about Nef's former (?) role as priest, Alex's attachment to the post-its, and the entire point about God as the super-director much more than is necessary. On the positive side, you make up for it once Alex leaves the graveyard. It's full-tilt action and shivers from there on out. I do wonder who these new people are -- ANOTHER haunted mansion? You do lead us an unmerry chase! The greenhouse gave me goosebumps: wonderful description of the squishy feel of the ground beneath his feet. One note: You might want to call it a conservatory. A greenhouse typically is a stand-alone building not connected to a house. For a moment, I thought he was back outside. It was just a mind trick caused by your choice of words.

Ahh, as for those other word choices: you had some masterpieces. "Almost holy, the post-its had become..." "The undulating darkness..." "Was it the hand of God that thrust his cold palm into mine..." Excellent descriptions.

All in all, a great read. Just needs tightening in the first quarter of the chapter.
1 out of 1 deviants thought this was fair.

Comments


Devious Comments

:iconlunaticstar:
Wuh oh. I can tell really where I messed up. It's not another place - its THE SAME place. Alex calls it a greenhouse because he doesn't know other words for a glass building (atrium, conservatory). He is a poorly educated ex-criminal who dropped out of high school to become a low level mafia runner. Dang. I figured the thing with the oak, the white house, and the glass building would tip people off.

And the first part is just rambling. I realize in my struggle to make Alex's side of things NOT be as mysterious as the Real Voice In My Head (Ahren) would want them to be, I've repeated myself a good 3 times on those points. Yay! To be edited. Thanks for the crit and time put into this nice little feature thingy. I'm milkin' my sub while it lasts!!

--
If wishes were horses, we'd all be eating steak. - Jayne, Firefly.
:icondenlm:
I didn't make the connection to Alex's lack of education, and I did know the room was inside. But the WORD greenhouse made me stumble for a moment, despite that. Some words by their very nature conjur up images you may not want your readers to see.
:iconlunaticstar:
The master has spoken. :bow: :bow: Changes will be changed when I change it. :D

--
If wishes were horses, we'd all be eating steak. - Jayne, Firefly.
:icondenlm:
Good enough. I shall put away my bullwhip.
:iconlunaticstar:
Grrr I don't know how to make this show up on the deviation! I think you only get one shot at it, if you delete it off your message list, the chance is up. SUCK!!

--
If wishes were horses, we'd all be eating steak. - Jayne, Firefly.

Site Map